Brookshaws & Sons All articles
From the Counter

The Case for the Bent Carrot: Buying, Storing and Cooking the Produce That Misses the Beauty Parade

Brookshaws & Sons
The Case for the Bent Carrot: Buying, Storing and Cooking the Produce That Misses the Beauty Parade

Photo: knobbly carrots marrow and windfall apples rustic grocer display UK, via cdn.ecommercedns.uk

The produce that fails the beauty parade is not a moral cause. It is simply good food, often at a better price, and it deserves a place in a sensible kitchen. At Brookshaws we have sold knobbly carrots, overgrown marrows and apples with a history of wind and wasp for longer than any of us can remember. The supermarket may call them imperfect. We prefer to call them dinner.

The Case Against Symmetry

A carrot does not need to be straight to be sweet. A marrow does not need to be small to be useful. The standards that govern supermarket produce are largely standards of travel and display: the vegetable must fit a box, survive a lorry and look the same as its neighbour. Flavour is not measured in the same way. When a root has grown slowly in a heavy soil, it may fork and twist; when an apple has been blown from the tree, it may bruise. Neither fault tells you anything about the quality of the eating.

This is not a romantic argument for ugliness. A soft carrot is a bad carrot. A marrow with a sour smell is not a bargain. The point is that cosmetic irregularity and poor condition are different things. One is a matter of shape; the other is a matter of keeping. A grocer learns to tell them apart, and so can a customer.

Choosing: Look for Character, Not Carelessness

For roots, choose firm specimens with unbroken skin and no damp patches. Bend is a warning. Small hairs and a little soil are not. A knobbly parsnip or a forked carrot will roast as well as a straight one, and often has a denser texture because it has not been pushed for size. For marrows, choose one that feels heavy for its length, with a hard skin and no soft spot at the blossom end. A very large marrow is best halved, seeded and stuffed; a smaller one can be sliced and fried. For windfall apples, inspect the bruise. A slight knock can be cut away; a brown, weeping patch cannot. Use windfalls quickly, and do not store them against sound fruit.

Storing: Cool, Dark and Not Too Precious

Roots keep best in a cool, dark place with some air. A shed, a garage or a ventilated larder is better than a warm kitchen. Remove the leafy tops from carrots and parsnips before storing, as the leaves draw moisture from the root. Marrows will sit happily on a shelf for weeks if the skin is sound and the air is dry; check them occasionally for soft spots. Apples should be stored separately from other produce because they give off ethylene, which hastens ripening in their neighbours. A single bruised apple can encourage the rest to follow.

The refrigerator is not a universal answer. It is useful for cut vegetables and for apples that are already ripe, but it can make raw roots sweaty and soft. The old advice was simple: keep things cool, keep them dry and keep an eye on them. That remains sound.

Three Honest Recipes

Roast marrow with mustard and breadcrumbs. Halve a marrow lengthways, scoop out the seeds and roast cut side down at 200C for twenty minutes. Turn it over, fill the hollow with fresh breadcrumbs, a spoonful of mustard, thyme and grated cheese, and return to the oven until the top is brown. This is not a fashionable dish. It is a good one.

Bent carrots with cumin and honey. Cut the carrots into long pieces, toss with oil, cumin seed and a little honey, and roast at 200C for twenty-five to thirty minutes. Do not crowd the tin. The irregular edges catch and caramelise, which is precisely the advantage of a carrot that has not been machined into uniformity.

Windfall apple chutney. Take one kilogram of peeled and chopped apples, two hundred and fifty grams of onions, one hundred and fifty grams of sugar and three hundred millilitres of vinegar. Add mustard seed, ginger and a chilli if you like. Simmer until thick, stirring now and then, then pot into warm jars. It will improve for a month and keep for a year.

Waste Without a Sermon

The easiest way to reduce waste is not to buy a heroic quantity of imperfect vegetables and then fail to cook them. Buy what you will use in a week. If a marrow is too large, ask for it to be cut, or plan to cook half and freeze the rest. Use the tops of carrots in stock, the cores of apples in jelly, the seeds of a marrow for nothing at all. This is not a lecture. It is simply the ordinary thrift that has always kept a kitchen going.

A bent carrot is not a symbol. It is a carrot. Buy it, cook it and judge it on the plate.

All Articles

Related Articles

A Shorter Shelf, a Clearer Shop: The Case for Not Stocking Everything

A Shorter Shelf, a Clearer Shop: The Case for Not Stocking Everything

Pinned, Written, Noticed: What the Shop Door Board Still Tells Us

Pinned, Written, Noticed: What the Shop Door Board Still Tells Us

The Rooms We Keep and the Life We Carry: A Practical Guide to Moving Somewhere Smaller

The Rooms We Keep and the Life We Carry: A Practical Guide to Moving Somewhere Smaller